Can Bread Over Rise or Rise For TOO Long? (Explained)

If you have ever baked bread, then you must be well aware that it is an unforgiving process. It is more akin to science than any other form of cooking. One misstep and you might find yourself starting all over again.

One of the major pain points for bread bakers is allowing the bread to rise. This got me thinking though, what happens if I forget about the bread and it rises longer than I expected?

Can bread over rise?

Bread dough can overrise which can cause the baked bread to taste sour and have a crumbly texture. Allowing bread to rise for too long will give the yeast more time to feed on the sugars and release more carbon dioxide, which creates more air bubbles. Bread that has risen for too long cannot be salvaged and should be tossed out.

The effects of an over risen bread range from salvageable texture change to utter disaster. The best thing to do is to make sure the bread is given the right amount of time to rise.

Bread that has risen for too long should be tossed out since the texture and flavor will change too much. It’s easier to start bread from scratch than salvaging a bread dough that has risen for too long.

Let’s cover some of the common issues with overrisen bread

Overrisen Bread Has Crumbly Texture

The first issue with overrisen bread dough is that the texture will change.

The process of rising works when yeast, which is a fungus, starts to eat the sugars in the bread and releases carbon dioxide and alcohols. The bubbles that you see in the air pockets are a result of this breakdown by the yeast.

If the yeast is given too much time and the bread overrise then the yeast will create more air bubbles than the recipe calls for. These extra air bubbles will create an overly porous and crumbly piece of bread.

Overrisen Bread Can Have An Odd Or Sour Flavor

Another issue with overrisen bread is that the taste of the bread can change.

The taste of bread is impacted by both the type of yeast that is used and the time the yeast has to convert sugars into carbon dioxide and alcohols.

The longer the yeast has to eat sugars means that there will be more alcohols released by the yeast. Typically yeast will give bread a pleasant earthy flavor. However, too much alcohol in the bread will make this flavor become more pronounced which can taste sour or odd.

This is sour or odd flavor is a common problem that a lot of bakers’ face when bread is allowed to rise in a warm environment.

Overrisen Bread Can Collapse Or Implode

The biggest issue with overrisen bread is that the baked bread can implode or collapse on itself.

Yeast that is given too much time to rise which converts more of the sugars into carbon dioxide will leave a porous bread. Bread that is very porous or that has a lot of holes in it can structural integrity issues.

The end result will be a baked bread that collapses on itself or implodes as the bread does not have enough strength to stand. There is no solution to this issue other than starting new bread from scratch and allowing it to rise with the correct amount of time.

Final Thoughts

If you find yourself staring at an over risen bread dough, then don’t be too hard on yourself.

Although there is little to be done in order to salvage the bread, you can take comfort in the fact that every bake makes this mistake.

Overrisen bread can still be baked and you can test for yourself to see if you like how the bread tastes or how the structure comes out. You might like allowing the bread to rise longer than the recipe calls for – after all bread baking is a scientific form of cooking.

We hope that you find this article helpful and wish you the best of luck with your bread baking!

Steven

Learn how to catch, grow, and cook your own food. Whether you're searching for food tips and recipes or growing your own plants, there's something for you here! So let's learn how to catch, grow, and cook our food together.

Recent Posts